Dynamic Index based selection from a list


Author
Message
Athanasia
Athanasia
Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 19, Visits: 58
Hello Dave!

According to a value (PSE number), which will be defined in the beginning of each experiment, I want to present only 6 out of 100 images, creating a unique set of 6 trials for each participant. The steps should be -15, -9, -3, +3, +9, and +15 from the PSE number. For example, if PSE is number 50, then the stimuli (pictures) presented to this participant will be Disgust_Fear_35/41/47/53/59/65.

Each picture Disgust_Fear_xx has two items (“a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”, “b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”). When picture Disgust_Fear_xx is presented as stimulus on a trial, the choice between a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp and b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp should be random.

I have tried to put all the picture elements in a list and select based on index, similar to what is proposed here  https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic13785.aspx

These are the relevant code parts:

<values>
/ primerPSE = 50
/ selectedImageNumber = 0
</values>

<picture Disgust_Fear_1>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<picture Disgust_Fear_99>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<list allPictures>
/items = ( picture.Disgust_Fear_1, picture.Disgust_Fear_2, picture.Disgust_Fear_3,… picture.Disgust_Fear_98, picture.Disgust_Fear_99)
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures **
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;
    ]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

The problem (denoted with ** above) is that I can’t put a list, or a picture element, as item of the picture pic.
I also tried to replace the list with an item element which will include the picture elements as items:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = picture.Disgust_Fear_1

/ 99 = picture.Disgust_Fear_99
</item>

But I understand that this is also invalid syntax.

My very first approach was
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = list.allPictures.item(values.selectedImageNumber); 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;],
but again, stimulustimes attribute does not work like that.

Another idea based on this topic https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic18863.aspx , is to create an item element with 200 items and then two lists of 100 like this:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = "28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"                
...        
/ 99 = "28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
/ 100 = "33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"            
...
/ 198 = "33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
</item>        
    
<list PicSelectorallPictures_1>
/ items = (1,2,...,98,99)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<list PicSelectorPictures_2>
/ items = (100,101,...197,198)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures
/ select = noreplace(list.PicSelectorallPictures_1.item(values.selectedImageNumber),
       list.PicSelectorPictures_2.item(values.selectedImageNumber))
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

but again, while the script is working, I don't have the picture I want.

Any other suggestions?

Thanks in advance for your help
Dave
Dave
Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)
Group: Administrators
Posts: 13K, Visits: 104K
Athanasia - 11/12/2020
Hello Dave!

According to a value (PSE number), which will be defined in the beginning of each experiment, I want to present only 6 out of 100 images, creating a unique set of 6 trials for each participant. The steps should be -15, -9, -3, +3, +9, and +15 from the PSE number. For example, if PSE is number 50, then the stimuli (pictures) presented to this participant will be Disgust_Fear_35/41/47/53/59/65.

Each picture Disgust_Fear_xx has two items (“a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”, “b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”). When picture Disgust_Fear_xx is presented as stimulus on a trial, the choice between a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp and b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp should be random.

I have tried to put all the picture elements in a list and select based on index, similar to what is proposed here  https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic13785.aspx

These are the relevant code parts:

<values>
/ primerPSE = 50
/ selectedImageNumber = 0
</values>

<picture Disgust_Fear_1>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<picture Disgust_Fear_99>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<list allPictures>
/items = ( picture.Disgust_Fear_1, picture.Disgust_Fear_2, picture.Disgust_Fear_3,… picture.Disgust_Fear_98, picture.Disgust_Fear_99)
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures **
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;
    ]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

The problem (denoted with ** above) is that I can’t put a list, or a picture element, as item of the picture pic.
I also tried to replace the list with an item element which will include the picture elements as items:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = picture.Disgust_Fear_1

/ 99 = picture.Disgust_Fear_99
</item>

But I understand that this is also invalid syntax.

My very first approach was
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = list.allPictures.item(values.selectedImageNumber); 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;],
but again, stimulustimes attribute does not work like that.

Another idea based on this topic https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic18863.aspx , is to create an item element with 200 items and then two lists of 100 like this:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = "28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"                
...        
/ 99 = "28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
/ 100 = "33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"            
...
/ 198 = "33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
</item>        
    
<list PicSelectorallPictures_1>
/ items = (1,2,...,98,99)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<list PicSelectorPictures_2>
/ items = (100,101,...197,198)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures
/ select = noreplace(list.PicSelectorallPictures_1.item(values.selectedImageNumber),
       list.PicSelectorPictures_2.item(values.selectedImageNumber))
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

but again, while the script is working, I don't have the picture I want.

Any other suggestions?

Thanks in advance for your help

<list allPictures>
/items = ( picture.Disgust_Fear_1, picture.Disgust_Fear_2, picture.Disgust_Fear_3,… picture.Disgust_Fear_98, picture.Disgust_Fear_99)
/ selectionmode = values.selecteditemnumber
</list>

with

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [
  trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
  values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;
  trial.minus15.insertstimulustime(list.allPictures.nextvalue, 1800);
  ]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>
Dave
Dave
Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)
Group: Administrators
Posts: 13K, Visits: 104K
Dave - 11/12/2020
Athanasia - 11/12/2020
Hello Dave!

According to a value (PSE number), which will be defined in the beginning of each experiment, I want to present only 6 out of 100 images, creating a unique set of 6 trials for each participant. The steps should be -15, -9, -3, +3, +9, and +15 from the PSE number. For example, if PSE is number 50, then the stimuli (pictures) presented to this participant will be Disgust_Fear_35/41/47/53/59/65.

Each picture Disgust_Fear_xx has two items (“a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”, “b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp”). When picture Disgust_Fear_xx is presented as stimulus on a trial, the choice between a_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp and b_Disgust_Fear_xx.bmp should be random.

I have tried to put all the picture elements in a list and select based on index, similar to what is proposed here  https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic13785.aspx

These are the relevant code parts:

<values>
/ primerPSE = 50
/ selectedImageNumber = 0
</values>

<picture Disgust_Fear_1>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<picture Disgust_Fear_99>
/ items = ("28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP","33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP")
/ size = (100%,100%)
/ position = (50,50)
/ select = noreplace
</picture>

<list allPictures>
/items = ( picture.Disgust_Fear_1, picture.Disgust_Fear_2, picture.Disgust_Fear_3,… picture.Disgust_Fear_98, picture.Disgust_Fear_99)
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures **
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;
    ]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

The problem (denoted with ** above) is that I can’t put a list, or a picture element, as item of the picture pic.
I also tried to replace the list with an item element which will include the picture elements as items:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = picture.Disgust_Fear_1

/ 99 = picture.Disgust_Fear_99
</item>

But I understand that this is also invalid syntax.

My very first approach was
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = list.allPictures.item(values.selectedImageNumber); 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;],
but again, stimulustimes attribute does not work like that.

Another idea based on this topic https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic18863.aspx , is to create an item element with 200 items and then two lists of 100 like this:

<item allPictures>
/ 1 = "28_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"                
...        
/ 99 = "28_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
/ 100 = "33_Disgust_Fear_1.BMP"            
...
/ 198 = "33_Disgust_Fear_99.BMP"            
</item>        
    
<list PicSelectorallPictures_1>
/ items = (1,2,...,98,99)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<list PicSelectorPictures_2>
/ items = (100,101,...197,198)
/ select = values.selectedImageNumber
</list>

<picture pic>
/ items = allPictures
/ select = noreplace(list.PicSelectorallPictures_1.item(values.selectedImageNumber),
       list.PicSelectorPictures_2.item(values.selectedImageNumber))
</picture>

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

but again, while the script is working, I don't have the picture I want.

Any other suggestions?

Thanks in advance for your help

<list allPictures>
/items = ( picture.Disgust_Fear_1, picture.Disgust_Fear_2, picture.Disgust_Fear_3,… picture.Disgust_Fear_98, picture.Disgust_Fear_99)
/ selectionmode = values.selecteditemnumber
</list>

with

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [
  trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
  values.selectedImageNumber = values.primerPSE - 15;
  trial.minus15.insertstimulustime(list.allPictures.nextvalue, 1800);
  ]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = Fixation; 1800 = pic; 2050 = Square; 2050 = Answer;]
/ pretrialpause = noreplace(750,1050,1350,1650,1950,2250,2550,2850)
/ beginresponsetime = 1800
/ response = timeout(2750)
/ validresponse = ("a", "l")
/ responseinterrupt = immediate
</trial>

Here's a simplified, self-contained example:

<values>
/ pse = 5
/ selectedtext = 0
</values>

<list alltexts>
/ items = (text.01, text.02, text.03, text.04, text.05, text.06, text.07, text.08, text.09, text.10)
/ selectionmode = values.selectedtext
</list>

<text 01>
/ items = ("01A", "01B")
</text>
<text 02>
/ items = ("02A", "02B")
</text>
<text 03>
/ items = ("03A", "03B")
</text>
<text 04>
/ items = ("04A", "04B")
</text>
<text 05>
/ items = ("05A", "05B")
</text>
<text 06>
/ items = ("06A", "06B")
</text>
<text 07>
/ items = ("07A", "07B")
</text>
<text 08>
/ items = ("08A", "08B")
</text>
<text 09>
/ items = ("09A", "09B")
</text>
<text 10>
/ items = ("10A", "101B")
</text>

<text fixation>
/ items = ("+")
</text>

// will yield text #3 with pse = 5
<trial minus2>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.minus2.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedtext = values.pse - 2;
    trial.minus2.insertstimulustime(list.alltexts.nextvalue, 2000);
]
/ stimulusframes = [1=fixation]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

// will yield text #8 with pse = 5
<trial plus3>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.plus3.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedtext = values.pse + 3;
    trial.plus3.insertstimulustime(list.alltexts.nextvalue, 2000);
]
/ stimulusframes = [1=fixation]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

<block example>
/ trials = [1-2 = noreplace(trial.minus2, trial.plus3)]
</block>


and

<values>
/ pse = 5
/ selectedtext = 0
</values>

<list alltexts>
/ items = (text.01, text.02, text.03, text.04, text.05, text.06, text.07, text.08, text.09, text.10)
/ selectionmode = values.selectedtext
</list>


<text 01>
/ items = ("01A", "01B")
</text>
<text 02>
/ items = ("02A", "02B")
</text>
<text 03>
/ items = ("03A", "03B")
</text>
<text 04>
/ items = ("04A", "04B")
</text>
<text 05>
/ items = ("05A", "05B")
</text>
<text 06>
/ items = ("06A", "06B")
</text>
<text 07>
/ items = ("07A", "07B")
</text>
<text 08>
/ items = ("08A", "08B")
</text>
<text 09>
/ items = ("09A", "09B")
</text>
<text 10>
/ items = ("10A", "101B")
</text>

<text fixation>
/ items = ("+")
</text>

<trial minus2>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.minus2.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedtext = values.pse - 2;
]
/ stimulustimes = [0=fixation; 2000 = list.alltexts]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

<trial plus3>
/ ontrialbegin = [
    trial.plus3.resetstimulusframes();
    values.selectedtext = values.pse + 3;
]
/ stimulustimes = [0=fixation; 2000 = list.alltexts]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

<block example>
/ trials = [1-2 = noreplace(trial.minus2, trial.plus3)]
</block>


will work just the same. The point is using the value computed from PSE as the index into the <list> of stimulus objects (<text>s in the case of the above examples, <picture>s in your case; it works the same with either).

Edited 4 Years Ago by Dave
Athanasia
Athanasia
Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 19, Visits: 58

Thank you Dave for your answer! It worked perfectly!

Another, thing I am struggling with is that there will be four ports (with 4 different odors) and I want each one of them to be coupled to one of the six trials creating 24 unique trials per block  (6 trials x 4 odors).
I created the ports as separate elements and then I tried to follow the logic above, by creating a list of ports, but again, I am missing something.

<port FearAA>
/ port = COM1
/ items = ("10101010")
</port>

<port FearGAGG>
/ port = COM2
/ items = ("10101000")
</port>

<port NeutralAA>
/ port = COM3
/ items = ("11101010")
</port>

<port NeutralGAGG>
/ port = COM4
/ items = ("10101110")
</port>

<list AllPorts>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
/ selectionrate = trial
/ selectionmode = list.AllPorts.nextvalue
</list>

<trial minus15>

/ stimulustimes = [0 = timer; 3000 = list.AllPorts; 3000 = INHALE;…]

</trial>

<block Disgust_L_Fear_R>

/ trials = [1-24 = noreplace(minus15,minus9,minus3,plus3,plus9,plus15)]

</block>

Thank you again for all your help and quick replies!

Dave
Dave
Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)Supreme Being (1M reputation)
Group: Administrators
Posts: 13K, Visits: 104K
Athanasia - 11/17/2020

Thank you Dave for your answer! It worked perfectly!

Another, thing I am struggling with is that there will be four ports (with 4 different odors) and I want each one of them to be coupled to one of the six trials creating 24 unique trials per block  (6 trials x 4 odors).
I created the ports as separate elements and then I tried to follow the logic above, by creating a list of ports, but again, I am missing something.

<port FearAA>
/ port = COM1
/ items = ("10101010")
</port>

<port FearGAGG>
/ port = COM2
/ items = ("10101000")
</port>

<port NeutralAA>
/ port = COM3
/ items = ("11101010")
</port>

<port NeutralGAGG>
/ port = COM4
/ items = ("10101110")
</port>

<list AllPorts>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
/ selectionrate = trial
/ selectionmode = list.AllPorts.nextvalue
</list>

<trial minus15>

/ stimulustimes = [0 = timer; 3000 = list.AllPorts; 3000 = INHALE;…]

</trial>

<block Disgust_L_Fear_R>

/ trials = [1-24 = noreplace(minus15,minus9,minus3,plus3,plus9,plus15)]

</block>

Thank you again for all your help and quick replies!

<list AllPorts>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
/ selectionrate = trial
/ selectionmode = list.AllPorts.nextvalue
</list>

This is circular. You cannot have the list perform its selection based on itself. Moreover, the nextvalue isn't an item index, it's a <port> object and hence unsuitable as an index.

What you want is one <list> per trial type

<list minus15_odors>
 / items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

<list minus9_odors>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

<list minus3_odors>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

<list plus3_odors>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

<list plus9_odors>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

<list plus15_odors>
/ items = (port.FearAA, port.FearGAGG, port.NeutralAA, port.NeutralGAGG)
</list>

and then sample port objects from that list in the applicable trial:

<trial minus15>
/ ontrialbegin = [trial.minus15.resetstimulusframes();
trial.minus15.insertstimulustime(list.minus15_odors.nextvalue, 3000);
]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = timer; 3000 = INHALE;…]

</trial>

<trial minus9>
/ ontrialbegin = [trial.minus9.resetstimulusframes();
trial.minus15.insertstimulustime(list.minus9_odors.nextvalue, 3000);
]
/ stimulustimes = [0 = timer; 3000 = INHALE;…]

</trial>

...


Athanasia
Athanasia
Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)Associate Member (261 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 19, Visits: 58

Thank you so much, for one more time! It works exactly as I want!
GO

Merge Selected

Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Reading This Topic

Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search