Follow-up question on: How to present texts depending on a previous selection?

Back

Home
»
Millisecond Forums
»
Inquisit 5
»
Follow-up question on: How to present texts depending on a previous...

Follow-up question on: How to present texts depending on a previous selection?

Follow-up question on: How to present texts depending on a previous...

Author	Message
kevin	kevin posted 8 Years Ago Topic Details Share Topic
Group: Forum Members Posts: 4, Visits: 26	Hi, two weeks ago, I posted a question relating to how to present certain information depending on an earlier choice made by participants (see here: https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic23027.aspx). Your advice really helped me a lot in solving this problem! Now I am in trouble with a follow-up question on that and I hope that you can help me out, again. In our study, we want to implement a recall task where participants have to indicate whether they have read a given sentence before or not. The selection of sentences presented in the recall task has to be adapted to the previously presented consumer reviews (see link above). This means that in the recall task one half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should have been indeed presented before (in the consumer reviews). The other half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should be distractors that had not been presented before (taken from a new list). Now, I would like to know how to program this recall task and whether it is possible to combine it with the previously posted code of yours. I would be really glad about getting another helpful response to my question. Best, Kevin
	Reply Like 42
Dave	Dave posted 8 Years Ago ANSWER Post Details Share Post
Group: Administrators Posts: 13K, Visits: 104K	+x kevin - Tuesday, December 19, 2017 Hi, two weeks ago, I posted a question relating to how to present certain information depending on an earlier choice made by participants (see here: https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic23027.aspx). Your advice really helped me a lot in solving this problem! Now I am in trouble with a follow-up question on that and I hope that you can help me out, again. In our study, we want to implement a recall task where participants have to indicate whether they have read a given sentence before or not. The selection of sentences presented in the recall task has to be adapted to the previously presented consumer reviews (see link above). This means that in the recall task one half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should have been indeed presented before (in the consumer reviews). The other half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should be distractors that had not been presented before (taken from a new list). Now, I would like to know how to program this recall task and whether it is possible to combine it with the previously posted code of yours. I would be really glad about getting another helpful response to my question. Best, Kevin This is a typical "old / new" task and such tasks have been discussed here before. See e.g. https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic17069.aspx or https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic21813.aspx
	Reply Like 36
kevin	kevin posted 8 Years Ago ANSWER Post Details Share Post
Group: Forum Members Posts: 4, Visits: 26	+x Dave - Tuesday, December 19, 2017 +x kevin - Tuesday, December 19, 2017 Hi, two weeks ago, I posted a question relating to how to present certain information depending on an earlier choice made by participants (see here: https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic23027.aspx). Your advice really helped me a lot in solving this problem! Now I am in trouble with a follow-up question on that and I hope that you can help me out, again. In our study, we want to implement a recall task where participants have to indicate whether they have read a given sentence before or not. The selection of sentences presented in the recall task has to be adapted to the previously presented consumer reviews (see link above). This means that in the recall task one half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should have been indeed presented before (in the consumer reviews). The other half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should be distractors that had not been presented before (taken from a new list). Now, I would like to know how to program this recall task and whether it is possible to combine it with the previously posted code of yours. I would be really glad about getting another helpful response to my question. Best, Kevin This is a typical "old / new" task and such tasks have been discussed here before. See e.g. https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic17069.aspx or https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic21813.aspx Hi Dave, thanks for posting the links. They helped me understand how these "old/new" tasks work in principal. However, I think that there is a difference with regard to my task. The items that form part of the 'old' list cannot be defined as a list in advance (as in the examples you posted), since they depend on which reviews had been previously presented. This presentation of reviews is in itself randomized, so I don't know which items are 'old' beforehand. Thus I would need a command that says "If review x had been presented, write all sentences of review x in the 'old' list". This command should be repeated for every review. In a second step, I would randomly choose a number of sentences from the 'old' list and an equal number of sentences from the 'new' list. The latter could be defined in advance, because it contains only sentences not presented in any review before. I hope this is understandable and maybe you could help me out with this issue. Thanks a lot, Kevin
	Reply Like 36
Dave	Dave posted 8 Years Ago ANSWER Post Details Share Post
Group: Administrators Posts: 13K, Visits: 104K	+x kevin - Friday, December 22, 2017 +x Dave - Tuesday, December 19, 2017 +x kevin - Tuesday, December 19, 2017 Hi, two weeks ago, I posted a question relating to how to present certain information depending on an earlier choice made by participants (see here: https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic23027.aspx). Your advice really helped me a lot in solving this problem! Now I am in trouble with a follow-up question on that and I hope that you can help me out, again. In our study, we want to implement a recall task where participants have to indicate whether they have read a given sentence before or not. The selection of sentences presented in the recall task has to be adapted to the previously presented consumer reviews (see link above). This means that in the recall task one half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should have been indeed presented before (in the consumer reviews). The other half of the sentences (i.e., 24) should be distractors that had not been presented before (taken from a new list). Now, I would like to know how to program this recall task and whether it is possible to combine it with the previously posted code of yours. I would be really glad about getting another helpful response to my question. Best, Kevin This is a typical "old / new" task and such tasks have been discussed here before. See e.g. https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic17069.aspx or https://www.millisecond.com/forums/Topic21813.aspx Hi Dave, thanks for posting the links. They helped me understand how these "old/new" tasks work in principal. However, I think that there is a difference with regard to my task. The items that form part of the 'old' list cannot be defined as a list in advance (as in the examples you posted), since they depend on which reviews had been previously presented. This presentation of reviews is in itself randomized, so I don't know which items are 'old' beforehand. Thus I would need a command that says "If review x had been presented, write all sentences of review x in the 'old' list". This command should be repeated for every review. In a second step, I would randomly choose a number of sentences from the 'old' list and an equal number of sentences from the 'new' list. The latter could be defined in advance, because it contains only sentences not presented in any review before. I hope this is understandable and maybe you could help me out with this issue. Thanks a lot, Kevin Your items are matched to your reviews ("since they depend on which reviews had been previously presented"). > This presentation of reviews is in itself randomized, so I don't know which items are 'old' beforehand. There is nothing that prevents you from determinining that at the start of the experiment, just like the examples illustrate. Before you show any reviews, select X at random. Select Y to "not be shown." In other words, you can exactly "know" which items are "old" and "new" in the 2nd part, you can do it all in one fell swoop at the start of the experiment, just as in the examples. Does that make more sense? Edited 8 Years Ago by Dave
	Reply Like 35

GO

Merge into selected topic...

Merge into merge target...

Merge into a specific topic ID...

Post Quoted Reply

Reading This Topic

Login
Remember Me Reset Password Resend Validation Email Login	Facebook

Explore

Messages

Mentions

Search